The Second City – Porto’s Centres and its Peripheries
‘There is a second city. Unreal, imaginary, made of demolished houses and never realised projects and yet all of them present. The majority of an architect’s work has to do with this second city; and it is never wasted effort… Architecture is risk, and risk requires impersonal desire and anonymity, starting with the fusion of subjectivity and objectivity. After all, with progressive distancing the I.’
— Álvaro Siza
Porto is famous as a city of architects attuned to the nuances of history and for reconciling this with the traditions of modern architecture. We thought that this is something that British architecture can learn from, so we decided to get to know more about the city and its architecture. In the first semester we studied a washhouse from the 1990s built by Paulo Providência in the city centre beside the old docks.
We also studied a park landscape built by Fernando Távora in the 1960s at Matosinhos, beside the new docks. We took these projects to be exemplary of ways of dealing directly with questions of use and technology, and they revealed to us also indirect ways of confronting questions of collective sociability and the problems of use and situation that functionalism cannot capture. Students proposed small-scale adjustments to the park and to the city centre of Porto, which sought to reveal the deeper social issues surrounding the ‘road engineering’ that afflicts the old town and the new docks.
This work was re-presented to Porto in a crit and seminars at FAUP and Guimarães (schools built by Siza and Távora). Then the students met Álvaro Siza to discuss some of his projects for recuperating Porto, sites that we had identified as places in need of architectural care. Siza was very generous with his time and articulated his own frustrations as an architect and all left the encounter refreshed.
We then produced an exhibition at The Cass and a publication, which documented the research and first design projects along with a film and transcription of the meeting with Siza. Alongside this event the architect Providência and the Porto critic Nuno Grande came to talk at our school in February 2011.
The work of the unit has focussed since then on collaborative approaches to five areas of central Porto and to the beach-park junction between Porto and Matosinhos. Students returned to Porto to interview local residents and architects and established programmatic briefs for design interventions based upon local knowledge as well as a situational and typological approach to urban problems. For example, the construction of various railways and ring roads has led to the succinct morphology of a stone hill-top city, dissolving into sprawl and to the creation of inner-city ghettos cut-off from the wealthy suburbs by ring-roads.
We seeked in Unit 2 to thinking long-term and to uncover remnants of ways of thinking about human habitat that has survived the 20th and 19th century’s obsessions with technology and the alienating ‘freedom’ that it produces at the expense of the city. Our responses to the urban and social problems of Porto and Matosinhos suggest ways in which technological impositions can be absorbed meaningfully into enduring human habitats. We have become used to only thinking in terms of urban renewal, but change doesn’t simply mean making things new again, sometimes cities need to be made old again. A better word to use when thinking about the profound effects destruction and rebuilding has upon our lives is what Siza calls “recuperar”. To recuperate means to bring back to life but also back to consciousness. The idea of the second city inspires recuperation of the city’s risks and failures, the progressive distancing of the I, bringing closer the other.
Diploma Unit 2, The Cass, London Metropolitan University
Academic year: 2010-11
Tutors: Patrick Lynch, Alun Jones, Paulo Moreira
Students: Amy Bradley Smith, Kieran Brash, Tim Burton, Emilia Maja Herman, Elaine Mc Quaid, Payal Patel, Elaine Radcliffe, Markus Nurkkala, Mathew Wickham, Tom Benton, Robert Chandler, Tyrone Deans, Inga Karan, Zeinab Rahal, Sophie Roycroft, James Woodward
Exhibitions: ‘The Second City’, ASD Gallery – Spring House, London (UK). 3-10.02.2011; ‘At First Sight’, The Sir John Cass Faculty of Art, Media & Design, London (UK). 15.3 – 13.4.2011;
Publication: ‘The Second City: Studies on Porto & its Peripheries’ (first semester work by Unit 2). ISBN: 978-0-9563532-2-1
With thanks to: Emanuel de Sousa, Ricardo Duque, David Knight, Hilary Koob-Sassen, Mariana Pestana, Mariana Rodrigues, Max Fordham, Joseph Rykwert, David Evans, Colin O’Sullivan, Sandra Martin, Simon Henley, Kieran Long, Bruno Silvestre, Jay Merrick (London); Rodrigo Brito, Jorge Correia, João Rosmaninho, André Tavares (Guimarães); Jorge Carvalho, Álvaro Domingues, Ren Ito, Ana Leite Fernandes, Pedro Levi Bismark, António Madureira, Teresa Novais, Pedro Polónia, Paulo Sousa, Luís Tavares Pereira, Ernst Tide Huesser, Nuno Travasso (Porto).
Special thanks to: Álvaro Siza, Paulo Providência, Nuno Grande